CCSS

R.1, R.2, R.6, R.8, R.9, W.1, W.4, W.7, SL.1

Someone Cheated. Should You Speak Up?

April and Liam saw Jason cheat on a test. Is reporting him the right thing to do?

Art by Marcelo Baez

    Liam says: It’s our duty to speak up.

    Hey, April: I know we both saw Jason using his phone to cheat on that science test last week. Shouldn’t we tell Mr. Knight? I don’t know about you, but I struggled through that test. It was hard. And watching Jason copy the answers from his phone made me furious

    Here’s the worst part, though. He got an A, and I got a B. He cheated, and I studied all night. It’s not fair that someone can get a perfect grade without putting in any effort

    But I’m not upset just because Jason got a better grade than I did. I’m worried that cheating is becoming a big problem. I just read about this study. It found that one in three students have used their cell phones to cheat. That’s out of control! Isn’t it our duty to help stop cheating at our school?

    I think that telling Mr. Knight what happened is the right thing to do. Cheating is serious, and it’s not something we can handle on our own. Jason needs to learn that what he did is just plain wrong. And the only way he’ll learn is by getting the grade he deserves. Can I count on you to back me up

Art by Marcelo Baez

    April says: There’s got to be a better way to handle it.

    You’re right, Liam. Cheating is not OK. But I don’t think telling Mr. Knight is the right way to deal with this situation

    Sure, I was disappointed when I saw Jason cheating. But let’s be honest: It’s not really affecting us at all. If he gets in trouble, his A will become an F. But your B will stay a B, and my C+ will stay a C+. His mistakes aren’t really our business.

    We also don’t know what led Jason to cheat on the test. Remember how he had the flu and missed a whole week of school? Maybe he fell behind and was feeling desperate. I don’t think it would be fair to get him in trouble if this is a onetime mistake.

    Jason is always nice to us, so let’s help him instead of hurting him. I think we should tell him that we saw him cheat. After all, he was pretty obvious. Knowing that people noticed might make him think twice about doing it again. We could even start a study group so we can all ace the next test. Are you with me?

ACTIVITY
Should April and Liam report Jason?

What to do: Use evidence from the article to support each side of this debate. Write the information on a separate piece of paper.

Yes! Jason needs to learn a lesson.

No! Let’s help him instead.

Leveled Articles (2)
PDF

Debate

Higher Level: Someone Cheated. Should You Speak Up?

Read or print a 800L-900L version of this article in magazine view.

PDF

Debate

Lower Level: Someone Cheated. Should You Speak Up?

Read or print a 500L-600L version of this article in magazine view.

Text-to-Speech