Standards

Where Does She Belong?

A new museum has opened in Egypt. It has some people asking: Who really owns the past?  

OLIVER LANG/DDP/AFP via Getty Images 

This is a statue of Nefertiti, an Egyptian queen who lived about 3,400 years ago. It is one of Egypt’s most famous artifacts.

Jim McMahon/Mapman ®

Egypt is a country in northeast Africa.

    Welcome to the Grand Egyptian Museum! Are you ready to step thousands of years into the past?

    A big statue of Ramses II—one of Egypt’s most powerful rulers—greets you. Stairs lead to a majestic view of the pyramids of Giza. And then there are the artifacts from inside King Tut’s tomb! They are being shown together for the first time.

    This museum opened last November. It displays more than 50,000 artifacts. But many Egyptians say the collection is not complete. Some of Egypt’s most important artifacts are in other countries. 

    Should those countries give them back?

    Welcome to the Grand Egyptian Museum! Here, you can step thousands of years into the past.

    A huge statue of Ramses II greets you. He was one of Egypt’s most powerful rulers. Stairs lead to a view of the pyramids of Giza. Then you see the artifacts from King Tut’s tomb! They are being shown together for the first time.

    This museum opened last November. It displays more than 50,000 artifacts. But many Egyptians say the collection is not complete. Some of Egypt’s most important artifacts are in other countries.

    Should those countries give them back?

    Welcome to the Grand Egyptian Museum! Are you ready to step thousands of years into the past?

    A huge statue of Ramses II—one of Egypt’s most powerful rulers—greets you. Stairs lead to a majestic view of the pyramids of Giza. And then there are the artifacts from inside King Tut’s tomb, which are being shown together for the first time!

    This museum opened last November. It displays more than 50,000 artifacts—but many Egyptians consider the collection incomplete because some of Egypt’s most important artifacts are in other countries.

    Should those countries give them back?

Digging Up the Past

    You may be wondering how so many of Egypt’s treasures ended up so far away. From the late 1800s to the mid-1900s, archaeologists from Europe traveled to Egypt. They searched for valuable objects from the past. 

    European museums often paid for these trips. They wanted to build their collections. The trips turned up dazzling relics. Archaeologists found beautiful statues, detailed carvings, and more. 

    Some of these artifacts were removed from Egypt with permission. Others were stolen and taken to distant lands. 

    But the details surrounding the removal of many of these objects aren’t clear. That’s true for some of Egypt’s most famous artifacts. 

    How did so many of Egypt’s treasures end up so far away? From the late 1800s to the mid-1900s, archaeologists from Europe traveled to Egypt. They searched for objects from the past.

    European museums often paid for these trips. They wanted to build their collections. Archaeologists found relics, such as statues, carvings, and more.

    Some of them were taken from Egypt with permission. Others were stolen.

    But it’s not clear how some other objects were removed. That’s true for some of Egypt’s most famous artifacts.

    Are you wondering how so many of Egypt’s treasures ended up so far away? Well, from the late 1800s to the mid-1900s, archaeologists from Europe traveled to Egypt. There, they searched for valuable objects from the past.

    European museums—with the goal of building their collections—often funded these trips, which turned up dazzling relics. Archaeologists found beautiful statues, detailed carvings, and more.

    Some of these artifacts were removed from Egypt with permission, but others were stolen and taken to distant lands.

    However, the details surrounding the removal of many of these objects—including some of Egypt’s most renowned artifacts—aren’t clear.

Ahmad Hasaballah/Getty Images

Ancient Treasures
The Grand Egyptian Museum opened last November. It displays more than 50,000 artifacts.

Stolen Treasures?

    Take the Nefertiti [neh-fer-TEE-tee] statue, for example. 

    In 1912, a German archaeologist named Ludwig Borchardt was digging in Egypt. He found a painted statue of Queen Nefertiti, who lived more than 3,000 years ago. Borchardt had permission to take some items he found back to Germany. But Egyptian officials say the Nefertiti statue wasn’t one of them. They claim he smuggled it out of the country.

    Then there’s the Rosetta Stone—a stone slab carved with text. It’s one of the most important discoveries of all time. It helped experts unlock the mysteries of hieroglyphics. (That’s a type of ancient Egyptian writing.) Both Egypt and England claim it as their own.

    Today the Nefertiti statue sits inside a glass case at a museum in Germany. The Rosetta Stone is on display at a museum in England. Egyptian archaeologist Zahi Hawass believes that’s unfair. For many Egyptians, these objects are a great source of national pride. “Their home should be the Grand Egyptian Museum,” Hawass says. 

    Let’s start with the Nefertiti [neh-fer-TEE-tee] statue.

    In 1912, Ludwig Borchardt was digging in Egypt. He was a German archaeologist. He found a statue of Queen Nefertiti. She lived more than 3,000 years ago. Borchardt had permission to take some items he found back to Germany. But Egyptian officials say he did not have permission to take the Nefertiti statue. They say he smuggled it out of the country.

    Then there’s the Rosetta Stone. It’s a stone slab. It’s carved with text. It’s one of the most important discoveries of all time. It helped experts understand hieroglyphics. (That’s a type of ancient Egyptian writing.) Both Egypt and England claim it as their own.

    Today the Nefertiti statue is at a museum in Germany. The Rosetta Stone is at a museum in England. Egyptian archaeologist Zahi Hawass says that’s unfair. For many Egyptians, these objects are a source of national pride. “Their home should be the Grand Egyptian Museum,” Hawass says.

    Take the Nefertiti [neh-fer-TEE-tee] statue, for example.

    In 1912, a German archaeologist named Ludwig Borchardt was digging in Egypt. He found a painted statue of Queen Nefertiti, who lived more than 3,000 years ago. Borchardt had permission to take some items he found back to Germany, but Egyptian officials say the Nefertiti statue wasn’t among them. They claim he smuggled it out of the country.

    Then there’s the Rosetta Stone—a stone slab carved with text. It’s one of the most important discoveries of all time because it helped experts unlock the mysteries of hieroglyphics, a type of ancient Egyptian writing. Both Egypt and England claim the slab as their own.

    Today the Nefertiti statue sits inside a glass case at a museum in Germany, and the Rosetta Stone is on display at a museum in England. Egyptian archaeologist Zahi Hawass believes that’s unfair. For many Egyptians, these objects are a great source of national pride. “Their home should be the Grand Egyptian Museum,” Hawass says.

 

Build Knowledge

Ancient Egypt

Ancient Egypt was one of the world’s first great civilizations. (A civilization is a large group of people who live and work together.) It began about 5,000 years ago near Egypt’s Nile River. There, ancient Egyptians built magnificent pyramids, temples, and tombs. They also left behind paintings, statues, and other works of art. Together these structures and objects have taught experts a great deal about our early world.

Ancient Egypt

Ancient Egypt was one of the world’s first great civilizations. (A civilization is a large group of people who live and work together.) It began about 5,000 years ago near Egypt’s Nile River. There, ancient Egyptians built magnificent pyramids, temples, and tombs. They also left behind paintings, statues, and other works of art. Together these structures and objects have taught experts a great deal about our early world.

Ancient Egypt

Ancient Egypt was one of the world’s first great civilizations. (A civilization is a large group of people who live and work together.) It began about 5,000 years ago near Egypt’s Nile River. There, ancient Egyptians built magnificent pyramids, temples, and tombs. They also left behind paintings, statues, and other works of art. Together these structures and objects have taught experts a great deal about our early world.

Shutterstock.com

The Debate Continues

    Not everyone agrees though. Some people believe the artifacts should stay in their current homes. Why? They say the relics get more attention in other countries. For example, the Rosetta Stone stands out at the museum in England. It’s one of a kind there. But Egypt has 22 similar objects that have helped experts understand hieroglyphics.

    Another argument is that many of these important artifacts are on display in the world’s biggest cities. A lot of people visit those museums. This can spark a deeper interest in Egypt. It might even inspire those visitors to travel to Egypt next. 

    Salima Ikram is an Egyptologist. (That’s someone who studies ancient Egypt.) She supports the return of the country’s key artifacts. However, she agrees that some of Egypt’s treasures should be on display around the world. “These artifacts make people want to visit Egypt and learn more about it,” she says.  “They inform, inspire, and delight people.”

    Over the past decade, about 30,000 relics have been returned to Egypt. Among them were artifacts that had long been in Belgium, the Netherlands, and the United States. 

    For many Egyptians, this is a hopeful sign. 

    “We cannot change the past,” says Egyptologist Monica Hanna. “But we can correct it.” 

    Not everyone agrees though. Some people say the artifacts should stay where they are now. Why? They say the relics get more attention in other countries. The Rosetta Stone stands out at the museum in England. It’s one of a kind there. But Egypt has 22 similar carved stones.

    Plus, many of these artifacts are on display in the world’s biggest cities. Many people visit those museums. They might become interested in Egypt. They might travel to Egypt next.

    Salima Ikram is an Egyptologist. (That’s someone who studies ancient Egypt.) She thinks the country’s key artifacts should be returned to Egypt. But she agrees that some items should stay on display around the world. “These artifacts make people want to visit Egypt and learn more about it,” she says. “They inform, inspire, and delight people.”

    Over the past decade, about 30,000 relics have been returned to Egypt. Some of them had been in Belgium, the Netherlands, and the United States.

    For many Egyptians, this brings hope.

    “We cannot change the past,” says Egyptologist Monica Hanna. “But we can correct it.” 

    Not everyone agrees though. Some people believe the artifacts should stay in their current homes. Why? They say the relics receive more attention in other countries. For example, the Rosetta Stone stands out at the museum in England, where it is one of a kind. In contrast, Egypt has 22 similar objects that have helped experts understand hieroglyphics.

    Another argument is that many of these important artifacts are on display in the world’s biggest cities. A great many people visit those museums, and seeing the artifacts there can spark a deeper interest in Egypt. It might even inspire those visitors to travel to Egypt next.

    Salima Ikram is an Egyptologist, someone who studies ancient Egypt. She supports the return of the country’s key artifacts. However, she agrees that some of Egypt’s treasures should be on display around the world. “These artifacts make people want to visit Egypt and learn more about it,” she says. “They inform, inspire, and delight people.”

    Over the past decade, about 30,000 relics have been returned to Egypt. Among them were artifacts that had long been in Belgium, the Netherlands, and the United States.

    For many Egyptians, this is a hopeful sign.

    “We cannot change the past,” says Monica Hanna, an Egyptologist. “But we can correct it.” 

Shutterstock.com

A Piece of History 
Last year, about 6 million visitors saw the Rosetta Stone. It is displayed at the British Museum in England.

 

ACTIVITY: 
5 Questions About
Egypt’s Treasures

What to do: Answer the questions below. Use full sentences. Write them on a separate sheet of paper.

What to do: Answer the questions below. Use full sentences. Write them on a separate sheet of paper.

What to do: Answer the questions below. Use full sentences. Write them on a separate sheet of paper.

When did the Grand Egyptian Museum open?

When did the Grand Egyptian Museum open?

When did the Grand Egyptian Museum open?

Who says the museum’s collection is not complete?

Who says the museum’s collection is not complete?

Who says the museum’s collection is not complete?

Where do these people say Egyptian artifacts belong?

Where do these people say Egyptian artifacts belong?

Where do these people say Egyptian artifacts belong?

What are some other countries that have Egyptian artifacts on display?

What are some other countries that have Egyptian artifacts on display?

What are some other countries that have Egyptian artifacts on display?

Why do some people support having Egyptian artifacts in other countries? 

Why do some people support having Egyptian artifacts in other countries? 

Why do some people support having Egyptian artifacts in other countries? 

videos (2)
videos (2)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Lesson Plan (1)
Leveled Articles (2)
Leveled Articles (2)
Text-to-Speech