CCSS

R.1, R.3, R.4, R.7, W.3, SL.1, SL.2, L.4, L.5, L.6

Stuffed!

Two men meet on Thanksgiving Day. Both of them are keeping a secret. How far will they go to hide the truth? 

Art by Lisa K. Weber

A City Scene  
This story is set in New York City in 1907. What does this picture tell you about the time period?

Based on the classic short story “Two Thanksgiving Day Gentlemen” by O. Henry

CHARACTERS

*Starred characters have larger speaking parts.

  • *Narrators 1, 2, & 3  (N1, N2, N3) 
  • *Stuffy Pete, a homeless man 
  • Servant
  • *Mr. Cross, an old gentleman  
  • Waiters 1 and 2 (W1, W2)   
  • Washerwoman
  • Doctors 1 and 2 (D1, D2)

PROLOGUE

N1: Ah, Thanksgiving!

N2: It is one of the most beloved American traditions.

N3: Every year, we come together and eat a delicious meal with our families. 

N1: We give thanks for the good things in our lives.

N2: Such a strong tradition feels like it’s been around forever. But that’s not true.

N3: When Thanksgiving became popular in the late 1800s, America itself was a relatively young country. 

N1: It had existed for just over 100 years.

N2: Our new country needed new holidays and traditions. How else would we set ourselves apart from others?

N3: So ever since, we travel to be with loved ones. We gather around tables to feast. 

N1: This yearly ritual makes us happy. 

N2: But you’re about to meet a couple of men who might make you wonder—

N3: How far would you go to keep up your Thanksgiving tradition?

SCENE 1

Fifth Avenue, New York City
Thanksgiving Day, 1907

N1: Stuffy Pete walks down the sidewalk. Horses pull carriages in the street. 

N2: People are bundled up against the cold. But Pete’s clothes are old, frayed, and covered in patches.  

N3: Still, he feels warm. He even whistles as he walks!

N1: He looks forward to this day all year. Today he knows he won’t go to bed hungry.

Pete: I’d better hurry. I don’t want to keep the old gentleman waiting.

N2: As Pete speeds up, he passes a beautiful house. A servant stands outside.

N3: The people of this house have their own Thanksgiving tradition.

Servant: Sir, are you hungry on this day of feasting?

Pete: Yes, I am. But—

Servant: The masters of this house wish to feed the first hungry person who passes by. Please, come in and eat!

Pete: That is very kind, sir. But every year I meet the same man for . . .  

N1: Just then, Pete looks through the window. He sees two rich old women sitting at a table. 

N2: On the table is a beautiful meal. His mouth waters.

Pete: Actually, I think I will come inside. Thank you for your generous invitation!

Art by Lisa K. Weber

Feasting on a Full Stomach
Would you eat all this food just to avoid telling the truth?

SCENE 2

Union Square Park, later that day

N3: Stuffy Pete sits on his usual bench, so full of food that he can barely move.

N1: The buttons on his shirt strain against his swollen stomach.

N2: His face is red and sweaty, and the snowy breeze feels cool on his skin.

N3: A thin old gentleman named Mr. Cross approaches Pete’s bench. His elegant suit hangs loosely on his body. 

N1: He leans heavily on his cane as he walks toward Pete, smiling.

Mr. Cross: Greetings, my good man!

Pete: Happy Thanksgiving, sir.

N2: This is the ninth year that the two have met on Thanksgiving Day. Mr. Cross has created his own Thanksgiving Day tradition with Pete. 

N3: The old man has no family of his own, so he spends the holiday with a stranger.

Mr. Cross: I am happy to see that the troubles of another year have not worn you down. You and I can both give thanks that we have our health on this holiday. Now, come with me and I will give you a dinner that will fill your belly and warm your heart!

N1: Mr. Cross gives the same speech every year. The words are a part of his tradition.

N2: Pete looks up at Mr. Cross with tears in his eyes. He wants to run away, but he is too full.

Pete: Sir, I—

N3: The words get stuck in Pete’s throat. He almost tells his Thanksgiving benefactor that he already ate. 

N1: But the old man looks so pleased. Stuffy Pete knows how much this ritual means to him each year.

Mr. Cross: Well? Shall we?

Pete (lying): Yes, thank you, sir. I am very hungry.

SCENE 3

A Nearby Restaurant

N2: Stuffy Pete and Mr. Cross enter. They go to their usual table in the corner.

Waiter 1: Here comes that rich old man. He buys that no-good bum a dinner every Thanksgiving.

Waiter 2: I wonder why he does it?

Mr. Cross: Waiter, please bring us turkey, soup, potatoes, pies—a feast for my good man here!

W1: Right away, sir.

N3: The waiters bring plate after plate of food to the table. 

W2: I hope you’re hungry!

Pete: Oh yes, I’m so grateful for this meal.

Mr. Cross: It’s nothing! I am pleased to know there will be one less empty belly in the city tonight.

W1 (quietly, to W2): Funny how rich folks only care whether the hungry have enough to eat on holidays.

W2: Isn’t that the truth.

N1: Stuffy Pete raises his fork and knife, like a soldier getting ready for battle.

Pete: Wouldn’t you like to have some, sir?

Mr. Cross: No, no, my friend. This is all for you.

N2: Stuffy Pete sighs and begins to eat. 

N3: Mr. Cross watches him with satisfaction. 

N1: Pete eats until he can barely breathe. After an hour, he sits back.

Pete: Thank you kindly, sir, for this hearty meal.

Mr. Cross: Please. It is my great pleasure.

N2: The two men stand up and exit the restaurant. 

N3: Mr. Cross goes north, and Pete heads south.

N1: After walking a block, Stuffy Pete falls to the ground.

Pete (moaning): Ohhhh, my stomach!

N2: A washerwoman heading home from work sees Pete on the sidewalk.

Washerwoman: Sir! Sir! Are you OK? 

N3: She shakes Pete, but he has passed out.

Washerwoman: Someone help! Hellllllp!

N1: An ambulance arrives and takes Pete to the hospital.

Art by Lisa K. Weber

Unhealthy Holiday  
How did both men end up in the hospital? The answer may surprise you!

SCENE 4

The Hospital

N2: The doctors wheel Stuffy Pete—heavy with his two meals—into a room. 

Doctor 1: I can’t figure out what’s wrong. He seems pretty healthy for a homeless man.

Doctor 2: His stomach is huge. Perhaps he ate too much at his Thanksgiving feast this year?

D1: But where would a man like this get such a meal?

N3: Soon, another patient is brought into the room. It’s old Mr. Cross!

N1: He lies on the bed next to Stuffy Pete’s bed. Pete is still sleeping.

N2: A few hours later, the doctors come back to check on their patients.

D2: The bum still isn’t awake, but he should be fine.

D1: This other man isn’t so lucky. Can you believe it? He looks so well-off. You wouldn’t know he was starving. 

D2: Proud old man, I guess. He told the nurse he hadn’t eaten in three days!

N3: One man starving, one man stuffed.

N1: They both risked their health to keep up a tradition.

N2: And so we ask again: How far would you go to do the same?

 

ACTIVITY:

Inference

Culture Club/Getty Images (O. Henry)

Meet the Author

O. Henry was known for his short stories. Many of them have surprising endings or crazy plot twists—just like this one!

You've just read "Stuffed!” Now it’s time to try this activity. 

Tip: An inference is something that is not stated but can be figured out from clues in the text.

What to do: Imagine that you are Stuffy Pete, right after the end of the story. You and Mr. Cross are still in the hospital, and you’re talking. Mr. Cross has some questions for you. Make inferences to answer each of Mr. Cross’s questions below with at least one complete sentence.

Mr. Cross: How did you feel when you first headed out to meet me?

Stuffy Pete:

Mr. Cross: Why didn’t you say no when those other people offered you a meal?

Stuffy Pete: 

Mr. Cross: If you were full after your first meal, why did you eat so much with me?

Stuffy Pete: 

Mr. Cross: How would you have felt if I’d accepted your offer to share the food?

Stuffy Pete: 

videos (1)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Lesson Plan (1)
Text-to-Speech